The film — a sequel to the 1997 unique and its 1998 followup, I Nonetheless Know What You Did Final Summer time — hit theaters Friday and it wasn’t lengthy till some viewers started speculating about scenes involving the 2 returning stars.

“Okay guys. Let’s spark a debate right here. Do you ACTUALLY suppose Jennifer Love Hewitt & Freddie Prinze Jr. filmed their scenes collectively for ‘I KNOW WHAT YOU DID LAST SUMMER’ (2025)?!” one viewer posted to X.

“Individuals are beginning to discover the ‘cuts and separate pictures’’ That is an excessive amount of lol,” they added, seemingly indicating they thought the hypothesis was BS themselves.

The 2 do seem in a number of scenes collectively within the film — for a spoiler-filled breakdown of the flick, click on right here.

“they completely shot their scenes collectively. hope this helps,” the film’s director, Jennifer Kaytin Robinson, later replied — whereas quote-tweeting the rumor to her personal feed.

The unique poster responded to her reply, writing, “I apologize for this, I am embarrassed! Thanks for educating us on every thing as a result of most administrators would by no means. You are feeding the fandom by stating details for the longer term. There’s so many issues we’re nonetheless studying about OLDER motion pictures, so it is nice that you just have interaction with us.”

Robinson replied to that as nicely, telling them there was “no apology essential.” She then added, “I completely get why individuals may suppose that reason for a few of the protection however they’re completely appearing off one another. It was electrical!”

Hewitt seems to have been the final to signal onto the film, asserting she was returning in December 2024 — a number of months after filming had already began in Australia.

Main as much as the movie’s launch, there’s been hypothesis a few feud between Hewitt and Prinze Jr.’s spouse, fellow OG IKWYDLS costar Sarah Michelle Gellar — one thing that continued into final week’s crimson carpet premiere.

Hypothesis there was some beef brewing between the 2 scream queens blew up on social media again in December 2024, all due to a crimson carpet interview Gellar did with EXTRA whereas on the premiere of Dexter: Unique Sin.

In the course of the interview, she was requested in regards to the new I Know What You Did Final Summer time sequel after Gellar shared a photograph from the set whereas husband Freddie Prinze Jr. was filming. After praising Robinson and the film’s “enjoyable” script, Gellar was requested about Hewitt probably returning as nicely. “I’ve nothing to do with that,” she responded, earlier than beginning to stroll away from the reporter.

The video blew up on X, racking up greater than 5 million views amid hypothesis on social media and within the YouTube feedback that one thing went down between the 2 stars. Gellar later took to Instagram to make clear she could not say something in regards to the film as a result of she signed an NDA — earlier than sharing the information when Hewitt was formally confirmed to return.

“I truthfully do not even know what that was or how that every one got here to be,” Hewitt instructed Vulture of the feud hypothesis in a latest profile. “I simply suppose individuals don’t desire the narrative to be straightforward. Why will we all the time must be towards one another and out for one another?”

“I have not seen Sarah,” she reportedly added when requested if she spoke with Gellar about it in any respect. “Actually, we have not talked since I noticed her at 18 years outdated when the primary film got here out. That is why it is so humorous to me. Folks had been like, ‘Say one thing again.’ And I am like, ‘What am I going to say? I’ve not seen her.’ On my aspect, we’re good. I do not know the place that is coming from.”

Hewitt instructed the reporter she hoped she’d see Gellar on the premier, although evidently did not occur — one thing which once more sparked feud rumors this week.

Gellar was available on the occasion together with her husband, who additionally stars within the new movie alongside Hewitt. Whereas the couple posed for photographs collectively and Gellar later snapped pics with former Buffy the Vampire Slayer costar Seth Inexperienced, followers had been disillusioned when she and Hewitt did not have a crimson carpet reunion of their very own.

Then, final Wednesday, Gellar shared a carousel of photographs from the premiere to Instagram — the place, once more, she wasn’t pictured with Hewitt and did not immediately point out her in her caption.

Nearly instantly, her feedback had been flooded with questions like, “The place is J Love? ”, “I like you, however the place’s Jennifer?” — in addition to feedback together with, “I like you so dearly, but it surely makes me so unhappy there may be ZERO recognition for Jennifer Lover Hewitt both” and hypothesis about “beef” between the 2.

Minutes after her preliminary submit, Gellar responded to followers questioning about Hewitt.

“For everybody asking – I by no means obtained to see @jenniferlovehewitt who’s implausible within the film,” she clarified in a remark. “I used to be inside with my children when the large carpet occurred. And sadly JLH did not come to the after occasion.”

“In case you have ever been to considered one of these it is loopy. I sadly did not get pics with many of the forged,” she continued. “However that does not change how superb I feel all of them are. Sadly some issues occur solely in actual life and never on-line.”

I Know What You Did Final Summer time is in theaters now.